Onchan MHK Peter Karran couldn't provide the House of Keys with evidence to support his recent claim that food prices in the Isle of Man were influenced by a cartel.
Instead, in response to Office of Fair Trading Chairman Quintin Gill's question, he called for the OFT itself to conduct an investigation.
Mr Gill had asked for the proof and also wanted to know why Mr Karran hadn't approached his office about the matter.
The Onchan member (pictured) said it wasn't up to him to do the OFT's job:
Hopes for better working relationship between government and hospitality sector
Follows private talks in what's described as a 'call to arms' meeting
'A lot of work to do' on low income housing
Chief Minister says facts are urgently needed
Public servants killed in the line of duty eligible for new award
Families encouraged to apply for Elizabeth Emblem
Multi-million pound Villiers development recommended for approval
Planning Committee due to make decision next week
IoM 'must use voice on international stage'
MHK says public's views must be represented
Rosalind Ranson row draws to a close
Tynwald debates the findings of a probe into its management
