Views on "flawed logic"
A review of Lord Lisvane's Tynwald inquiry report has been published by an expert on Manx Public Law.
Professor Peter Edge is a lecturer at Oxford Brookes University - he posted his interpretation of the recommendations on the UK Constitutional Law Association online forum.
It takes the form of an overview of the functions of Tynwald - with a critical view on how it can be improved, and where Lord Lisvane's logic is flawed.
Election of the Chief Minister, scrutiny roles, departmental membership, and focus on diversity in the House of Keys were all topics up for discussion.
Professor Edge says the current system isn't ideal:
Disruption at Ronaldsway airport following incident with light aircraft
Hopes for better working relationship between government and hospitality sector
'A lot of work to do' on low income housing
Public servants killed in the line of duty eligible for new award
Multi-million pound Villiers development recommended for approval
Rosalind Ranson row draws to a close
